
Clerk Magistrate Hearing in Massachusetts: What to Expect
A clerk magistrate hearing in Massachusetts is a short, closed-door hearing where a court official decides whether a criminal complaint should issue against you at all. It applies when someone has applied for a complaint but you were not arrested. Under G.L. c. 218, § 35A, a person facing a misdemeanor complaint who is not under arrest must be given notice and a chance to be heard, in person or through a lawyer, before the complaint issues. If it does not issue, no criminal case is opened.
This guide covers the general criminal side: shoplifting, minor assault and battery, threats, property damage, trespass and similar charges. For drunk driving cases, see our separate guide on the OUI clerk magistrate hearing, which works differently because most OUI cases start with an arrest. This is general information, not legal advice.
Got a hearing notice from a Bristol County court? Call Bank & Munns at 401-573-2265 or visit 21 Douglas Ave, Providence, RI 02908.
What the Notice in Your Mailbox Means
The notice says that a police officer or a private person has filed an application for a criminal complaint naming you. Nothing has been charged yet. There is no docket number, no arraignment date and no plea. The notice gives a date, a time and the court, and it tells you how to be heard.
The notice is not a summons to arraignment. Those are different papers. If yours says arraignment, the complaint has already issued and this guide is not your next step. Read our guide to Bristol County arraignment instead.
What Section 35A Requires
| Point | What the statute and court standards say |
|---|---|
| Who gets a hearing | A person not under arrest for the offense, when the complaint is for a misdemeanor |
| Felony complaints | A hearing is not guaranteed the same way it is for a misdemeanor |
| Exceptions | An imminent threat of bodily injury, of a crime, or of flight from Massachusetts |
| Records checked | Your criminal record and the statewide domestic violence record system |
| How you can be heard | Personally or through a lawyer |
| The standard | The complaint can issue unless there is no probable cause |
Probable cause is a low bar. It is far below proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The clerk magistrate is not deciding guilt. The only question is whether the facts in the application, if believed, show probable cause for each element of the offense and that you are the person who did it.
Who Brings the Application
Most applications come from police after an investigation where no one was arrested on the spot. Private citizens can also apply, for example a neighbor in a property dispute, a store after a shoplifting stop, or a person in a fight that police did not see. Private applications often turn on a personal dispute, and that context can matter at the hearing.
If the person who filed the application does not show up, the application may be denied. You should still show up.
What Happens at the Hearing
- The clerk magistrate calls the matter, often in a small room rather than a courtroom.
- The officer or the private complainant summarizes the facts.
- You or your lawyer respond. That can mean pointing out a missing element, a wrong identity, or facts the application leaves out.
- The clerk magistrate may ask questions of both sides.
- The clerk decides, sometimes on the spot and sometimes later by mail.
What you say can be used later if a complaint issues. Many people do better letting a lawyer speak for them. Decide that ahead of time, not in the room.
Possible Outcomes
| Outcome | What it means for you |
|---|---|
| Complaint denied | No criminal case opens. A new application on the same facts generally needs additional evidence that was not presented the first time. |
| Complaint issues | The case gets a docket number and a summons for arraignment in District Court. |
| Decision held or continued | Some clerks put off a decision to a later date before ruling. Get the new date in writing. |
If a complaint issues without a required hearing, or without probable cause in the record, the remedy is a motion to dismiss after arraignment. Our guide on how to dismiss charges in Massachusetts explains that route.
Which Bristol County Court Holds the Hearing
The District Court for the town where the incident happened holds the hearing.
| District Court | Towns served |
|---|---|
| Attleboro | Attleboro, Mansfield, North Attleboro, Norton |
| Fall River | Fall River, Freetown, Somerset, Swansea, Westport |
| New Bedford | Acushnet, Dartmouth, Fairhaven, Freetown, New Bedford, Westport |
| Taunton | Berkley, Dighton, Easton, Raynham, Rehoboth, Seekonk, Taunton |
Freetown and Westport appear on two lists, so go by the court printed on your notice.
How to Prepare
- Get the application and any police report to a lawyer as soon as the notice arrives.
- Write a short timeline of what happened, with dates and names.
- Gather receipts, texts, photos or other records that support your side.
- List witnesses and how to reach them.
- Do not contact the complainant about the case.
- Confirm the date and room with the clerk magistrate office the week before.
If You Miss the Hearing
The hearing goes on without your side. The complainant still has to show probable cause, but nobody is there to answer it. If the complaint issues, a summons for arraignment follows, and missing that date can lead to a warrant. See missed court date in Massachusetts for what to do next.
For broader help with a Massachusetts charge, see our Massachusetts criminal defense lawyer page. Bank & Munns is a Rhode Island criminal defense lawyer firm that also handles cases in the Bristol County area courts listed above.
Related Reading
- Bristol County Arraignment
- Missed Court Date in Massachusetts
- How to Dismiss Charges in Massachusetts District Court
- CWOF for OUI in Massachusetts
- Massachusetts OUI vs Rhode Island DUI
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a clerk magistrate hearing the same as being charged?
No. An application has been filed, but no complaint has issued. The hearing decides whether one should. If the clerk denies the application, no criminal case is opened.
Do I have to attend the hearing?
You are not required to, but skipping it gives up your chance to oppose the complaint. The clerk will hear only the other side, and a complaint that issues leads to an arraignment date.
Can a lawyer speak for me at the hearing?
Yes. Section 35A lets you be heard personally or through a lawyer. A lawyer can review the application in advance and argue the probable cause question for you.
What standard does the clerk magistrate use?
Probable cause. The complaint can issue unless there is no probable cause to believe you committed the offense. It is a much lower standard than the one used at trial.
Do I get a hearing on a felony application?
Not always. The statute guarantees the hearing for misdemeanor complaints against a person not under arrest. Felony complaints are treated differently, so ask a lawyer about your notice.